By Andy Ives, CFP®, AIF®
IRA Analyst
The delineation between contingent and successor beneficiaries often creates confusion. Both are considered “next in line,” but the similarities end there. Here is a basic summary of the two:
Contingent Beneficiaries. “Contingent” – Subject to chance. Occurring or existing only if certain circumstances are the case. “What are your contingency plans?”
When an IRA owner dies, we look to the beneficiary form to determine who should receive the IRA funds. The beneficiary could be a person, trust, charity, or any number of possible entities. The moment an IRA owner dies, the primary beneficiary is immediately considered the new owner of those assets.
If, however, the primary beneficiary has predeceased the IRA owner, or if the primary beneficiary disclaims all or part of the assets, we are then forced to look to the next level on the beneficiary form – the contingent (or “secondary”) beneficiary. For example, if the first-team point guard on the basketball team is unable to play, the backup steps in. As such, the contingent beneficiary effectively moves up to the starting rotation, at which point he has all the normal benefits and options of a primary beneficiary. His participation in the game is contingent upon the person in front of him being unable (or unwilling) to play.
Despite the importance of having a bench player ready when needed, not all IRA owners fill out their reserve roster. Time and time again, IRA owners fail to name any beneficiary, let alone a contingent beneficiary. It is imperative to always name both a primary and a contingent beneficiary on an IRA account. If there is no contingent beneficiary and the primary beneficiary predeceases the account owner (or disclaims), the IRA will pass to the beneficiary named under the default language in the custodial document. Oftentimes that will be the estate of the deceased IRA owner, which may not produce the intended result.
Successor Beneficiaries. “Successor” – One that follows.
A successor beneficiary is nothing more than the next person in line to inherit. For a successor beneficiary to exist, there must have already been a previous beneficiary (and an inherited account). The original account must have already been passed to the previous beneficiary, and now it is being passed to the next beneficiary, as dictated by the beneficiary form completed by the previous beneficiary owner.A successor beneficiary is simply the beneficiary of a beneficiary.
Example: John opened an IRA and named his adult daughter Blaire as his primary beneficiary and his sister Patricia as contingent. John died, and Blaire inherited the entire IRA. Since primary beneficiary Blaire inherited the entire account, Patricia (as contingent) received nothing. On her inherited IRA, Blaire named her husband David as her primary beneficiary and her son Charlie as contingent. Since this is already an inherited IRA, both David and Charlie are also successor beneficiaries.
If you have technical questions you would like to have answered, be sure to submit them to mailbag@irahelp.com, to be answered on an upcoming Slott Report Mailbag, published every Thursday.
https://irahelp.com/contingent-vs-successor-beneficiaries/